Miranda Rights
Written in plain language for general understanding. This is educational content, not legal advice. Based on federal statutes and official sources.
What is this right?
If police arrest you and want to question you, they must first tell you: you have the right to remain silent, anything you say can be used against you in court, and you have the right to a lawyer. These are your Miranda rights.
If police question you without reading these rights, your answers generally cannot be used against you at trial. But Miranda only applies to custodial interrogation — meaning you are not free to leave AND police are asking you questions.
When does it apply?
This right applies when:
- You are in police custody (arrested or not free to leave)
- Police want to interrogate you (ask questions designed to get incriminating answers)
- Both conditions must be met — custody AND interrogation
Common misconceptions:
- "Police have to read me my rights when they arrest me" — Not automatically. They only must read Miranda if they want to question you. An arrest without Miranda warnings is still valid.
- "If they didn't read me my rights, my case gets thrown out" — No. It means your statements during questioning may be excluded, but other evidence still stands.
- "Anything I say before Miranda can't be used" — Voluntary statements made before custody (like blurting something out) can be used even without Miranda warnings.
What should you do?
Step 1: Say clearly: "I am invoking my right to remain silent." Then stop talking. You must explicitly invoke this right — simply staying quiet may not be enough after Berghuis v. Thompkins (2010).
Step 2: Say: "I want a lawyer." Once you request an attorney, police must stop questioning you until your lawyer is present.
Step 3: Do not answer questions, make small talk, or try to explain your side. Anything you say — even casual conversation — can be used against you.
Step 4: Stay calm and cooperative physically. You can refuse to answer questions while still complying with lawful orders (like sitting down or putting your hands where they can see them).
What should you NOT do?
Don't waive your rights. Police may say "it'll be easier if you just talk to us" or "only guilty people ask for lawyers." These are interrogation tactics. Exercise your rights.
Don't partially invoke your rights. Saying "maybe I should get a lawyer" is ambiguous. Be clear and direct: "I want a lawyer. I will not answer questions."
Don't consent to anything. Miranda covers questioning, but don't also consent to searches. Say: "I do not consent to any searches."
Don't resist physically. Even if your rights are being violated, physical resistance makes the situation worse and can lead to additional charges. Fight it in court, not on the street.
How New York differs from federal law
New York follows federal Miranda rules with some important procedural differences:
- Right to counsel (indelible right): Once a New York attorney enters a case — by filing a notice of appearance or by being present — police cannot question the suspect outside the attorney's presence, even if the suspect wants to talk. This is broader than federal Miranda.
- CPL § 60.45: New York's statutory suppression rules independently require Miranda-like warnings. Statements obtained in violation can be suppressed under state law even if they'd survive federal Miranda analysis.
- Prompt arraignment: NY requires prompt arraignment after arrest. Unnecessarily delayed arraignment (used to continue interrogation) can result in suppression of statements.
Additional Steps in New York
Contact the New York Civil Liberties Union (NYCLU) or file a complaint with the Civilian Complaint Review Board (CCRB) in NYC.
Relevant Law: NY Criminal Procedure Law § 60.45, NY Constitution Art. I, § 6, People v. Rogers (48 N.Y.2d 167, 1979)
Legal Resources
We may earn a commission if you use these services — at no extra cost to you. This supports our mission to make legal information free for everyone.