Rights During Detention in New South Wales
Reviewed by the Commoner Law Editorial Team. Sourced from Commonwealth Acts of Parliament, federal regulations, and official government guidance. State-level information reflects each state's own Acts and court decisions. Written in plain language for general understanding — this is educational content, not legal advice. Our editorial standards
What is this right?
Under sections 23C to 23E of the Crimes Act 1914 (Cth), after arrest for a Commonwealth offence police must bring you before a magistrate or judge as soon as practicable. Indefinite detention for questioning isn't allowed — and the High Court reinforced that in Williams v The Queen (1986).
The investigation period has to wrap up in a reasonable time. Police have an initial window and can apply to a magistrate for extensions if they can justify them. Time spent waiting for a lawyer, resting, or getting medical treatment is generally not counted against the investigation clock — that's the "dead time" carve-out under s. 23CA.
During detention you have the right to be treated humanely: adequate food, water, rest, and toilet access. Medical attention must be arranged if you need it. You also have the right to contact a friend or family member to let them know where you are (s. 23G).
If police exceed the lawful investigation period without charging you or producing you before a court, the continued detention may be unlawful — with consequences for any evidence obtained during that period.
When does it apply?
These rights apply from the moment you are arrested for a Commonwealth offence until you are either charged and brought before a court or released.
- They apply to all people, including non-citizens and visitors.
- Vulnerable persons (people under 18, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander persons, and those with a mental impairment) have additional protections, including the right to an interview friend.
- Different time limits apply for terrorism-related offences, where police may detain you for longer periods under special provisions.
What to Do If You Are Held in Australian Federal Police Detention
- Ask: "How long can you hold me?" and "When will I be taken before a magistrate?"
- Request food, water, and rest if you need them — police are required to provide these.
- Ask to contact a family member or friend to let them know where you are.
- If you feel unwell, request medical attention — police must arrange it.
- Keep track of how long you have been detained and note any periods of questioning versus waiting.
What should you NOT do?
- Don't assume you must answer questions to speed up your release — you have the right to silence throughout your detention.
- Don't refuse to cooperate with identification procedures that police are lawfully entitled to carry out (such as fingerprinting under s 3ZJ).
- Don't attempt to leave the police station without being formally released — this could lead to additional charges.
- Don't waive your rights under pressure — ask for a lawyer if you are unsure about anything.
How New South Wales differs from federal law
When detained by NSW Police, your rights are set out in Part 9 of LEPRA. These rights apply from the moment you are arrested and taken into custody.
- You must be informed of your rights — right to silence, right to a lawyer, right to contact a friend or relative, right to an interpreter, and right to medical attention — through a Part 9 caution.
- The maximum investigation period is 4 hours from when you are first detained (LEPRA, s 115). This can be extended by a magistrate up to an additional 8 hours. Time spent waiting for a lawyer, interpreter, or receiving medical treatment is generally excluded from the 4-hour count.
- You must be treated with humanity and respect for human dignity. Police must provide food, water, access to toilet facilities, and medical attention if needed.
- Special protections exist for vulnerable persons: children must have a support person present during questioning; Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander persons must have the Aboriginal Legal Service notified; and persons with cognitive impairment must have an appropriate support person.
- After the investigation period, you must be either charged, released, or brought before a magistrate.
Additional Steps in New South Wales
If your detention rights are violated, inform your lawyer immediately. Breaches of Part 9 can result in evidence being excluded at trial. Contact the LECC (1800 657 079) to lodge complaints about treatment in custody.
Relevant Law: Law Enforcement (Powers and Responsibilities) Act 2002 (NSW), Part 9, ss 111-133; Crimes (Forensic Procedures) Act 2000 (NSW)
Common Questions
When does rights during detention apply?
These rights apply from the moment you are arrested for a Commonwealth offence until you are either charged and brought before a court or released.They apply to all people, including non-citizens and visitors.Vulnerable persons (people under 18, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander persons, and those with a mental impairment) have additional protections, including the right to an interview friend.Different time limits apply for terrorism-related offences, where police may detain you for longer periods under special provisions.
What should I do if I am being held in custody by Australian Federal Police?
Ask: "How long can you hold me?" and "When will I be taken before a magistrate?"Request food, water, and rest if you need them — police are required to provide these.Ask to contact a family member or friend to let them know where you are.If you feel unwell, request medical attention — police must arrange it.Keep track of how long you have been detained and note any periods of questioning versus waiting.
What mistakes should I avoid with rights during detention?
Don't assume you must answer questions to speed up your release — you have the right to silence throughout your detention.Don't refuse to cooperate with identification procedures that police are lawfully entitled to carry out (such as fingerprinting under s 3ZJ).Don't attempt to leave the police station without being formally released — this could lead to additional charges.Don't waive your rights under pressure — ask for a lawyer if you are unsure about anything.
Rights During Detention in other states
Same topic, different jurisdiction. Pick the one that applies to you.