You're reading the New York version.Change state →
NY

Right to Repairs in New York

Researched by , Head Researcher

Primary sources cited; not legal advice.

Last verified:

Source: Implied warranty of habitability (common law, recognized in most states since Javins v. First National Realty Corp., 428 F.2d 1071, D.C. Cir. 1970). State repair-and-deduct statutes vary — examples: Cal. Civ. Code § 1942, Tex. Prop. Code § 92.0561, 765 Ill. Comp. Stat. 742/5, Mass. Gen. Laws ch. 111 § 127L. HUD housing quality standards (24 CFR § 982.401) for Section 8 tenants.

About this article

Sourced from primary statutes (U.S. Code, CFR, state compiled statutes) and official government agency guidance. Written in plain language for general understanding — this is educational content, not legal advice. Our editorial standards

New York Law

Primary statute: N.Y. Real Prop. Law § 235-b + NYC Civil Court Act § 110(c)

How New York differs from federal law

New York tenants have four distinct repair remedies stacked together — most states offer one. The HP proceeding is unique to NYC; the repair-and-deduct right is available statewide under common law.

Remedy 1 — HP proceeding (NYC only)

The HP (Housing Part) proceeding under NYC Civil Court Act § 110(c) is a summary proceeding specifically designed to compel repairs. Unlike ordinary civil suits, it moves on an expedited calendar and HPD acts as your co-prosecutor.

  • File the Order to Show Cause at Housing Court. Pro se forms at each borough's Help Center.
  • Filing fee $45; CPLR § 1101 poor person order waives fee.
  • HPD is automatically named as a party; HPD sends an inspector and testifies at the return date.
  • Return date ~1–2 weeks. Court can issue Order to Correct with statutory deadline.
  • Civil penalties $10–$50/day per violation (Admin Code § 27-2115), payable to the tenant's rent-abatement escrow or to the City.
  • Contempt for non-compliance — additional fines, potential criminal contempt for egregious cases.

Remedy 2 — Repair-and-deduct (statewide common law)

NY tenants may make necessary habitability repairs and deduct the reasonable cost from rent when the landlord has been notified and failed to act in a reasonable time (Jangla Realty Co. v. Gravagna, 112 Misc. 2d 642). Procedure:

  1. Written notice to landlord specifying the defective condition. Certified mail, return receipt.
  2. Reasonable time to cure — varies by severity (24 hours for no heat in winter; 7–14 days for typical repairs).
  3. Get 2+ written estimates from licensed contractors. Choose the reasonable one.
  4. Hire the contractor, retain receipts.
  5. Deduct from next rent payment with a written itemization attached to your rent check/transfer.
  6. Do not exceed actual cost. Repairs must be necessary, not cosmetic.

This remedy is judge-scrutinized — document compulsively and prefer the HP proceeding or rent abatement if the repair is expensive or risks eviction.

Remedy 3 — Rent withholding + § 235-b counterclaim

  • Stop paying rent and escrow it in your own account.
  • When the landlord sues for nonpayment, answer within 10 days (RPAPL § 732) and counterclaim under § 235-b.
  • Court awards retroactive abatement (10–100% of rent during the defective period).
  • Release of escrowed funds back to you if you prevail.

Remedy 4 — HPD Emergency Repair Program (NYC)

For Class C immediately hazardous violations (no heat, gas leak, lead paint, severe vermin), if the landlord does not correct within 24 hours, HPD can hire its own contractor and bill the landlord. Filed via 311; HPD prioritizes these complaints.

Multiple Dwelling Law (buildings of 3+ units)

  • § 78: Owners must keep the premises in good repair.
  • § 80: Adequate common-area lighting.
  • § 82: Pest extermination.
  • Violations of MDL duties are independently actionable and support heightened damages.

NYC Housing Maintenance Code — Admin Code § 27-2001 et seq.

  • Minimum temperature, hot water, sanitary conditions, pest control, structural integrity, smoke/CO detectors, lead paint abatement.
  • Every HMC violation is an independent basis for HP relief.
  • HPD Online (hpdonline.nyc.gov) lets you look up all violations on your building.

Attorney's fees — RPL § 234

Reciprocal fee-shifting from any landlord fee clause in the lease. Prevailing tenants in HP proceedings and § 235-b cases regularly recover attorney's fees.

Outside NYC — non-HP routes

  • Upstate: Use local code enforcement + small claims / justice court for damages.
  • Buffalo and Rochester have housing courts with HP-equivalent procedures.
  • Westchester, Nassau, Suffolk: County code enforcement + state court § 235-b claims.

Right to Counsel — NYC Local Law 136 of 2017

Tenants ≤200% FPL in all 5 boroughs get a free attorney in HP proceedings and housing court. Request at first appearance.

Tactical sequence

  1. Document with timestamped photos and written notice to landlord.
  2. Call 311 (NYC) for HPD inspection.
  3. Wait for HPD to issue violations — they become prosecutorial evidence.
  4. File HP proceeding if landlord hasn't fixed within the class-based statutory window.
  5. Request RPL § 234 attorney's fees + Civil penalties under § 27-2115.

Statute of limitations

6 years for § 235-b contract-based claims (CPLR § 213(2)).

Additional Steps in New York

Step 1 — Written notice: Certified mail to landlord specifying defect.

Step 2 — HPD complaint: 311 or portal.311.nyc.gov. Get reference number.

Step 3 — Look up violations: hpdonline.nyc.gov to track issued violations.

Step 4 — HP proceeding: Housing Court Order to Show Cause. Pro se packets at Help Centers. Civil penalties $10–$50/day + RPL § 234 attorney's fees.

Right to Counsel: Free attorney if ≤200% FPL.

Free legal help: Legal Aid Society (212) 577-3300; Legal Services NYC (917) 661-4500; Lawhelp.org/NY.

Relevant Law: N.Y. Real Prop. Law § 235-b (warranty of habitability); NYC Civil Court Act § 110(c) (HP proceedings); NYC Admin. Code § 27-2001 et seq. (Housing Maintenance Code); NYC Admin. Code § 27-2115 (civil penalties); NY Multiple Dwelling Law §§ 78, 80, 82 (3+ unit buildings); N.Y. Real Prop. Law § 234 (reciprocal attorney's fees); RPAPL § 732 (answer deadlines); NYC Local Law 136 of 2017 (Right to Counsel); NY CPLR § 213(2) (6-year SOL); <em>Jangla Realty v. Gravagna</em>, 112 Misc. 2d 642 (repair-and-deduct)

Federal baseline: Right to Repairs nationwide

What is this right?

As a tenant, you have the right to live in a unit that is safe and functional. When something breaks — plumbing, heating, electrical systems, or appliances included in your lease — your landlord is generally required to fix it within a reasonable time after you report it. This obligation flows from the implied warranty of habitability and state landlord-tenant statutes.

If your landlord ignores repair requests, many states give you the right to repair and deduct — hire someone to fix the problem yourself and deduct the cost from your rent. Other remedies include withholding rent (through legal escrow processes), filing code enforcement complaints, or breaking your lease without penalty.

When does it apply?

Your right to repairs applies when:

  • A condition in your rental unit affects health, safety, or habitability — broken heating, plumbing leaks, pest infestations, mold, faulty electrical, broken locks
  • The problem was not caused by you or your guests
  • You have notified your landlord of the problem (written notice is always best)
  • The landlord has had a reasonable time to make the repair and has failed to do so

Common repair remedies by state:

  • Repair and deduct: Available in most states. You hire a repair person, pay for it, and deduct the cost from rent. States impose limits (often one month's rent) and require written notice to the landlord first.
  • Rent withholding/escrow: Some states allow you to deposit rent into a court escrow account until repairs are made. You cannot simply stop paying — follow your state's legal process.
  • Code enforcement: Report violations to your local building or health inspector. They can order the landlord to make repairs and impose fines for noncompliance.
  • Lease termination: If conditions are severe enough ("constructive eviction"), you may be able to break your lease without penalty.

Common misconceptions:

  • "My landlord isn't responsible because it's an old building" — Age doesn't matter. The warranty of habitability applies regardless of when the building was constructed.
  • "I can just withhold rent until they fix it" — In most states, you cannot simply stop paying. You must follow specific legal procedures (escrow, repair-and-deduct) or risk eviction for nonpayment.
  • "Cosmetic issues count" — A dripping faucet, chipped paint, or squeaky door typically doesn't rise to the level of a habitability violation. The problem must affect health, safety, or basic livability.

What to Do If Your Landlord Won't Make Repairs

Step 1: Report the problem to your landlord in writing. Describe the issue, include photos, and request a repair by a specific date (typically 14-30 days for non-emergencies, 24-48 hours for emergencies like no heat or water). Keep a copy of your notice.

Step 2: If the landlord doesn't respond, send a second written notice referencing your first request and stating that you will pursue legal remedies if the repair is not made.

Step 3: If the landlord still doesn't act, exercise the remedy available in your state — repair and deduct, rent escrow, or code enforcement complaint. Follow your state's specific procedures exactly.

Step 4: For serious health and safety issues, contact your local building inspector or health department. They can inspect, issue violations, and compel repairs.

Step 5: If the situation is severe or your landlord retaliates, consult a tenant rights attorney. You may be entitled to rent abatement, damages, or lease termination.

What should you NOT do?

Don't make repairs without following your state's legal process. If you deduct from rent without proper notice or exceed the allowed amount, your landlord may claim nonpayment and pursue eviction.

Don't withhold rent without putting it in escrow (in states that require escrow). Courts view rent withholding without escrow unfavorably.

Don't ignore the problem. Small issues (a minor leak) can become major ones (mold, water damage). Report problems early and in writing.

Don't assume your lease overrides the law. A lease clause that says "landlord is not responsible for repairs" is unenforceable in most states. The implied warranty of habitability cannot be waived.

New York stacks four repair remedies — HP proceeding, rent withholding, repair-and-deduct, and HPD Emergency Repair — backed by civil penalties up to $50/day per violation.

Answer a few questions. We generate a personalized letter citing your state's exact statutes, deadlines, and penalties — ready to print and send in minutes.

Lawyers charge $350+. Your letter: $19.

Repair Request$19Security Deposit$19Rent Increase Objection$19Lease Violation Dispute$19
See all 8 letter types →

Common Questions

What exactly does "repair and deduct" cap at in my state?

Most repair-and-deduct statutes cap the deduction at one month's rent per 12-month period (CA Civ. Code §1942, IL 765 ILCS 742/5). Texas caps at one month's rent or $500, whichever is greater. Massachusetts allows up to 4 months' rent in total. Using the remedy more than the statutory cap is treated as rent nonpayment — check your state's limit before hiring a contractor.

Can I use repair-and-deduct for an appliance that wasn't in the lease?

No. Repair-and-deduct covers fixtures and systems the lease obligates the landlord to maintain — plumbing, heating, structural elements, supplied appliances. If you bought the fridge yourself, or the lease says "appliances as-is," you cannot deduct repair costs from rent. Get it in writing before you buy a used appliance with the landlord.

Do I have to use the cheapest contractor?

Courts require the repair to be "reasonable" — meaning market rate from a qualified professional, not the absolute cheapest available. Get at least one written estimate and keep the invoice. Inflated costs (hiring a friend at 2× market) are the easiest way for a landlord to void your deduction in court.

What if the landlord starts eviction after I deducted repairs?

Show up with: (1) your pre-repair written notice with a certified-mail receipt, (2) the invoice and proof of payment, (3) photos of the problem before and after. If your notice and deduction complied with the statute exactly, the eviction for nonpayment fails — the rent you deducted is not "unpaid." If the landlord files anyway, the retaliation presumption (usually 6–12 months) may also apply.

Right to Repairs in other states

Same topic, different jurisdiction. Pick the one that applies to you.

More in Housing Rights

Eviction Rights (in New York)Your landlord cannot just throw you out. Every state in the country requires written notice, a court filing, and a judge...Read more →Security Deposits (in New York)Security deposit law is one of the few places where tenants almost always have the upper hand — if they know the rules. ...Read more →Habitability Standards (in New York)The implied warranty of habitability is the rule that says a landlord can't rent you a place that isn't fit to live in. ...Read more →

Related Topics

Consumer RightsData Privacy Rights (in New York) →Family LawChild Support Rights (in New York) →
← Browse all Housing Rights

Legal Resources

We may earn a commission if you use these services — at no extra cost to you. This supports our mission to make legal information free for everyone.

Lemonade Renters InsuranceProtect your belongings and liability starting at $5/month. Know your rights, protect your stuff.Get a Quote →

Last verified:

You came here to know your rights — help someone else know theirs.

Support This Mission