Right to Silence
Written in plain language for general understanding. This is educational content, not legal advice. Based on UK Acts of Parliament, statutory instruments, and official guidance.
What is this right?
You have the right not to answer police questions. However, since 1994 the law allows a court to draw adverse inferences (negative conclusions) from your silence in certain situations.
The caution tells you: "You do not have to say anything. But it may harm your defence if you do not mention when questioned something which you later rely on in court."
This means: if you stay silent during police questioning and then raise a defence for the first time in court, the jury can be told to consider why you didn't mention it earlier.
When does it apply?
- Adverse inferences can only be drawn if you were cautioned and had access to legal advice before the interview.
- If you were denied a solicitor, no adverse inference should be drawn from your silence during that period.
- Inferences alone can never be enough to convict you — there must be other evidence too.
- In practice, your solicitor will advise you whether to answer questions, give a prepared statement, or remain silent — this depends on the evidence against you.
What should you do?
- Always get a solicitor before deciding whether to speak. The solicitor can help you decide what to say.
- A common approach is a prepared statement — a written statement your solicitor drafts with your account, read out at the start of the interview. You then answer "no comment" to further questions.
- If your solicitor advises you to give "no comment" answers, follow that advice — courts recognise that silence on legal advice is reasonable.
- You must provide your name and address in certain situations (e.g., when driving, or when asked under specific legislation).
What should you NOT do?
- Don't give a rambling account without speaking to a solicitor first — anything you say can be used against you.
- Don't lie — a proven lie is far worse than silence and can be used as evidence of guilt.
- Don't assume silence always hurts you — there are many valid reasons to exercise your right to silence, and courts must consider the circumstances.
How Scotland differs from UK national law
Scotland has a stronger right to silence than England & Wales:
- The Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994 (which allows adverse inferences from silence) does not apply in Scotland.
- In Scotland, a court or jury cannot draw negative conclusions from your decision to remain silent during police questioning.
- Your right to silence is more robust — staying silent cannot be used against you at trial.
Additional Steps in Scotland
- Even with this stronger protection, always consult a solicitor before deciding what to say.
Relevant Law: Common law; Criminal Procedure (Scotland) Act 1995
Legal Resources
We may earn a commission if you use these services — at no extra cost to you. This supports our mission to make legal information free for everyone.